Is American Airlines the best US airline?

Who is the better airline in America of all?

It provides scheduled passenger and cargo services throughout the world, particularly in the United States. American is currently operating with a fleet of more than 300 flying machines; it offers around 3,000 flights daily; its hub is located all across the United States; and it wants to turn into one of the most successful airlines in its domestic market. However, this has led many people to question whether the size and scope of the airline make it the ‘best’ airline in the US. The criteria to arrive at this determination include the following:.

Reliability and Performance

Of all the factors determining an airline’s service quality, punctuality and on-time arrival are some of the most crucial. The data provided by the US Department of Transportation show that the on-time arrival rate of American Airlines across the first eleven months of 2022 is 79, 98 %. This ranks them fifth among the leading ten airlines in the United States of America, following Hawaiian, Delta, United, and Alaska Airlines. Even though America reports good on-time figures, it ranks relatively low compared to other major carriers.

It also incurred more cancellation rates, baggage issues, and consumer complaints than other major American airline companies such as Delta Airlines and Southwest Airlines in 2022. The former and latter show that, in terms of operational and customer service efficiency, America cannot meet the bar set by some competitors.

Route Network and Hubs

American Airlines is one of the world’s biggest airline companies and indeed, it operates a large number of routes that connect many cities in the United States and other cities around the world. It conducts nearly 6,800 flights every day to approximately 350 locations in over 50 different countries.

Within the United States, America’s hubs are Dallas/Fort Worth, Charlotte, Chicago O’Hare, Los Angeles, Miami, New York JFK, Philadelphia, Phoenix, and Washington, DC, providing customers many choices for connecting to and from business destinations or leisurely vacation areas in the United States. However, other airlines like Delta and United Airlines can also be considered to have a wide network and multiple hubs connecting domestic locations.

Therefore, the reality of having a broad network scope on its own doesn’t make America the ‘best’ US airline since customers have similar other choices. But it does give the airline the potential to serve customers in much of the country and, therefore, more potential to increase market share.

Fleet and Seating

American has a large mainline fleet consisting mainly of Airbus and Boeing narrow-body aircraft, which are deployed on shorter domestic routes, combined with the company’s wide-body Boeing 777 and Boeing 787 for longer international flights. The total number of aircraft is nearly 1,600, including regional companies that provide the airline with strong transportation capacity.

Inside its planes, America has what it calls the main cabin, which is just the standard economy, and Main Cabin Extra seating, which is available on most routes. It also offers lie-flat business-class products on most of its wide-body aircraft and the majority of its newly acquired narrow-bodied planes. These amenities allow customers to decide on the level of comfort they want and are willing to pay during their stay on board.

However, America is still in the process of retrofitting the premium economy seats as well as adding new cabins in portions of its planes. Delta, JetBlue, and Alaska have a more balanced and up-to-date cabin product across its fleet. America has a lot of planes in the sky, but it does not have the glitz or the newest gems in the 3 A’s (amenities, accommodations, and ambiance).

Frequent Flyer Program

It’s interesting to note that American Airlines continues to hold one of the biggest global frequent flyer programs in the form of AAdvantage. This ensures that the client gets numerous chances to earn Airmiles along with elite status whenever they are flying with Americans. This program cooperates with many hotel brands, car rentals, and credit card companies for more revenues and redemptions too.

Nevertheless, the company still has millions of members of the AAdvantage program; however, some research studies indicate that customers find some features of the AAdvantage program more complex than those of the competitors and are not as satisfied with the program as they are with the competitor’s programs. For instance, Delta SkyMiles can be seen to perform exceptionally well when it comes to factors such as redemption value flexibility and upgrade priority, among others, which are preferred by most travelers. Thus, America offers the scale but is not exceptionally strong in this area to provide the highest quality of loyalty programs.

Prices and Fees

Generally, pricing is a critical factor that influences or appeals to the decision of a customer when they are choosing an airline to travel with. America has also annulled change fees for the majority of domestic economy tickets during the COVID-19 period. This makes it convenient for many travelers who are concerned with volatility or flexibility in their schedule and options.

However, it is also important to note that, yes, Americans still have paid options such as seat selection, checked baggage, and numerous other fees. What is more, base fares are also not always the lowest ones in all the markets, consistently. There are other ULCCs, such as Spirit and Allegiant, that offer even lower basic fares for bare-bone flying. Some examples include free check-in and open seating for added value by carriers such as Southwest. So, America is not always superior in terms of the lowest out-of-pocket expenses.

Staff and Service Quality

It is also important to note that an airline could propose detailed and expansive schedule changes and large networks if only it was backed and executed by its staff. Here, the company’s American has faced some challenges in the recent past. This carrier reported broad operation disruptions at the tail end of 2021 and in the early part of 2022 due to adverse weather conditions, technological breakdowns, and general staff deficits. These issues resulted in high cancellation and delay rates concerning the clients.

Though it is also equally vulnerable to such external forces, this paper has received a lot of criticism towards American Airlines for its inefficiency in performing reliably and getting back on its feet during irregular operations. Unions have also accused America’s approach to managing labor relations throughout the bankruptcies that affected the airline in the early 2000s of affecting morale, recruitment, and retention. Since there is a higher incidence of public complaints alongside internal personnel issues, it is apparent that American does not rank at the top amongst its rival airlines in so far as staff and customer service quality are concerned.

The Best?

When evaluating the carrier on factors such as reliability, food and beverage choices, loyalty programs, fare price points, and staff friendliness, it is clear that America has its strengths and weaknesses as it competes with other airlines. A large number of hubs in the major metros and a vast network of planes give America an expansivescale for serving numerous customers. Nevertheless, some shortcomings in operational and labor aspects have diminished performance reliability and service levels recently. However, it competes directly with some airlines by offering more seating, better fees, rewards, and even brand image, such as Delta, JetBlue, Southwest, and Alaska.

It means that no one today can confidently state that Carrier X is the best without reservation for some criterion or another. Many other factors can also influence decisions, such as price sensitivity, preferred travel dates and times, status benefits obtained, and cabin and amenity choice. However, when one compares industry quality indicators such as those mentioned above over the last couple of years, American is evident to have fallen behind other competitors in enough aspects to dismiss it from being a contender for the ‘best’ US airline. In contrast with the near-term focus of the recently struggling company, the path towards recovering lost ground will take a longer time for this one.

Yes, America still dominates the domestic and international markets but has much to do to catch up to the benchmark of some of the custodians of the industry, especially in areas to do with dependability, service delivery consistency, premium services, and brand image. There is a great opportunity to grow but the airline has operational vulnerabilities it needs to fix as well as improve its products and offerings to customers. Before that, other carriers would likely be considered more suitable in terms of overall quality by US passengers. Thus So American is a major avatar but does not occupy the position of a definitive and universally recognized “best” according to performance and passenger satisfaction indices.

Book your American Airlines ticket now and experience comfort and reliability. Call +1 833-902-2090 to speak with our travel experts.